how to stop negative thoughts: 6 tactics from martin seligman, naval, julie smith and more
“What does not come naturally and needs learning is being an optimist.”
the short version
the six tactics
argue with the voice like it is a rival: Martin Seligman on Modern Wisdom
7 tactics in ~81 minutes (4866s). 160K views on YouTube, per the Podex page. Seligman founded positive psychology and spent decades studying learned helplessness. this play is tactic 01, Argue With Your Catastrophic Voice Like It's A Rival.
Seligman says we inherited a brain from ice age ancestors that leans toward the worst. on the captions: "What does not come naturally and needs learning is being an optimist." at 84 he still woke at 4 in the morning before this interview, sure he was too old for it. his line: "I am still a pessimist, but I've learned optimism." so he treated the voice "as if it was a rival for my job or my wife", one "whose mission in life was to make me miserable", and argued back with a fact: "I did an interview last week with someone like Chris." the key is that the argument is real, not cheerful: "what we have on our sides is realism." he says people who learn this are better off half a year later: "6 months later, people are more optimistic, less depressed, less anxious."
the tactic: answer the thought like a lawyer, not a cheerleader. one real piece of evidence beats ten nice sentences.
try this week: each time a harsh thought shows up, write it down word for word. under it, write one fact from your own life that argues against it, like a time it went fine. do this for at least three thoughts before sunday.
Martin Seligman, Modern Wisdom
Argue With Your Catastrophic Voice Like It's A Rival
Cross-examine each catastrophic thought with specific situational evidence instead of accepting it as true.
Martin Seligman says
I treat my catastrophic voice like a rival trying to undermine me, and I argue back with realistic evidence instead of accepting it. Learning to dispute automatic thoughts is what actually converts pessimism into optimism. Six months after people learn this, they measure as more optimistic, less depressed, and less anxious.
Try this
Argue back against your catastrophic thought with specific realistic evidence instead of accepting it as true.
run the worst case, best case, most likely case: Martin Seligman on Modern Wisdom
same Modern Wisdom episode. the Podex page lists this as tactic 02, Run The Worst Case, Best Case, Most Likely Case Drill. Seligman says he taught a version of it to 40,000 drill sergeants in the US Army.
Seligman calls this putting it in perspective, and he says he taught it to "40,000 drill sergeants" in the US Army. his example: at noon on friday your manager emails you to come and see her at 4. most of us jump straight to being fired, because "we're catastrophizers". so the drill goes in three steps. first, "we have people imagine the very worst that could happen" and really get into it. then: "Now, what's the best thing that could happen", like a raise and a promotion for the memo you wrote. then: "Now, what's the most likely outcome?" in his example, she liked the memo and wants you to cut the budget. the last question turns the worry into a plan: "What can you do now to prepare for the 4:00 interview?" he calls it one of "about 15 different exercises that change pessimism into optimism".
the tactic: do not stop at the worst case. put the best case next to it, then pick the most likely one and prepare for that.
try this week: next time you dread something (a meeting, a message, a result), take a note and write three lines: worst case, best case, most likely. under the most likely one, write one thing you can do today to prepare, and do it.
name the pattern so the spiral gets shorter: Aaron Levie on My First Million
5 tactics in ~56 minutes (3376s). 23K views on YouTube, per the Podex page. Levie co-founded Box and runs it as CEO. this play is tactic 03, Name The Catastrophe So You Can Shorten The Spiral. on YouTube the episode is titled A $3.6B founder's honest take on the software market right now.
asked about a win from therapy, Levie names one word. his therapist said he catastrophized: on the captions, "I get one piece of news and then I instantly extrapolate out to like the worst possible outcome." one person quits, and in his head that "means the entire company's out of business". what changed was the name. once he could spot it, he could tell himself: "I know what this is. I've seen this 20 other times or 50 other times", and "It doesn't mean the end of the world." before, one piece of bad news could knock him out for days. now he goes through it and thinks: "Okay, this is like totally survivable." it did not make him calm by nature: a personality test put him at "a 99 out of 100 on being neurotic". the name just makes each spiral shorter.
the tactic: give your favorite thinking trap a name. when you can name it in the moment, you stop treating it as news.
try this week: pick the trap you fall into most (jumping to the worst case, mind reading, it is all my fault). give it a short name. every time you catch it, say the name and write a tally mark. on sunday, count the marks.
treat your mind like a loud roommate: Naval Ravikant on The Tim Ferriss Show
8 tactics in ~122 minutes (7295s). 1.3M views on YouTube, per the Podex page. Naval co-founded AngelList. this play is tactic 05, Watch Your Thoughts Like An Outside Observer. on YouTube the episode is titled Naval Ravikant on Happiness, Anxiety, and More.
Naval's point is that you did not pick most of your thoughts. on the captions: "it's not like i decided to have this thought". so he asks of his own mind what he would ask of anyone else: "is this true, is it correct, has it been correct in the past". he does it "literally just walking around". the payoff: "applying that same filter to my own thoughts gives me a level of peace and distance from them". he credits the crazy roommate idea to Michael Singer's The Untethered Soul: with a roommate who rambles in fear all day, "you would eventually tell your roommate to shut up or you would tell them to start justifying their claims". your thoughts "should be viewed with the same level of skepticism that you would apply to an outside observer".
the tactic: listen to your thoughts like they came from someone else. you would not believe a stranger who panics all day. do not believe the voice either.
try this week: on one walk a day, no headphones, notice each loud thought and ask Naval's questions: is this true, has it been right before, is it just scared? afterwards, write down the one thought that fell apart fastest.
let the thought be there, then choose your next move: Dr Julie Smith on The Diary Of A CEO
12 tactics in ~96 minutes (5770s). 4.8M views on YouTube, per the Podex page. Smith is a clinical psychologist. this play is tactic 11, Detach From Intrusive Thoughts, plus tactic 07, Make Affirmations Instructional, Not Declarative. the open tactic below is box breathing.
Smith is not a fan of only positive vibes. on the captions, thoughts show up anyway: "that's your brain offering up ideas opinions judgments narratives". fighting them backfires, because "when you try not to have a thought you're already having it". what works is the second step: "if you allow them all to be there and then you choose consciously what to do with them next or how much time to spend with each one". she is careful with affirmations. if you do not believe the line, repeating it "sets up this internal argument where your mind also chips in with the reasons that you're not". her fix: "affirmations can be more helpful when they're instructional". and if thinking does not shift a bad mood, "sometimes the quickest way to impact on your mind is through your body".
the tactic: stop trying to delete the thought. let it sit there, then pick what you do next.
try this week: swap one affirmation you do not believe for an instruction: not I am confident, but when my hands shake, I breathe out slowly and say my first line. when a harsh thought shows up, note it, let it be, and do the next planned thing.
Dr Julie Smith, The Diary of a CEO
Use Box Breathing To Interrupt A Panic Spiral
Trace a box shape with your eyes while breathing in-hold-out-hold on each side, or just make your out-breath longer and more forceful than your in-breath, to physically slow a panic spiral in real time.
Dr Julie Smith says
I slow the breath first because I can't directly slow my heart rate, but breath and heart rate are linked. I use box breathing, tracing a box shape while I breathe in, hold, out, hold, because it gives an anxious mind something visual to follow. I make the out-breath longer and more forceful than the in-breath because that calms the stress response fastest.
Try this
Trace a box shape while breathing in-hold-out-hold, or lengthen the out-breath past the in-breath, to calm the stress response.
break the loop by moving your attention: Dr Sahar Yousef on The Diary Of A CEO
12 tactics in ~135 minutes (8094s). 2.1M views on YouTube, per the Podex page. Yousef is a neuroscientist at UC Berkeley. this play is tactic 10, Interrupt Rumination Cycles. on YouTube the episode is titled Phone Addiction Scientist: Doing This Gives You An Hour Back Every Day!
asked if her advice applies to negative thinking and rumination, she says yes. on the captions: "Rumination is sort of the same thought over and over and over again. The only way out is to break the cycle." replaying the same story in the same words does not wear it out. she says it does the opposite: "If you keep doing that, you're just deepening and deepening that neural network." her method has two steps: "acknowledge why it's happening in the first place and then quite quickly after that redirect your attention when it's happening". then feed a different story: "What's a different version of the story? What's the narrative that you want to feed?" her tactic 12, for stuck problems, says the same: "Walk away and go do something else."
the tactic: when the same thought comes back, do not replay it again. name why it is there, then move your attention on purpose.
try this week: write down the one thought you replay most. next to it, write one sentence on why it keeps coming back and one redirect you will use (a walk, a call, a task you can finish in ten minutes). use the redirect every time the loop starts.
a one-week plan to stop negative thoughts
pick by problem
the voice says you are not good enough, and you believe it: Martin Seligman.
the play: argue back with one real fact from your own life, like a rival you want to beat.
you always expect the worst outcome: Martin Seligman.
the play: write the worst, best and most likely case, then prepare for the most likely one.
one piece of bad news ruins your whole week: Aaron Levie.
the play: name your thinking trap, so you recognize it the next time and the spiral gets shorter.
your mind chatters all day and you take every word seriously: Naval Ravikant.
the play: question your thoughts on a walk like they came from a loud roommate.
the harder you push a thought away, the louder it gets: Dr Julie Smith.
the play: let the thought be there, then choose what you do next. make affirmations instructions.
you keep replaying the same bad moment: Dr Sahar Yousef.
the play: name why the loop is there, then move your attention to something else on purpose.
what this is not
every page above has more plays behind the free one: Seligman's wash one cup, Naval's sit for 60 minutes for 60 days, Smith's map the argument cycle on paper, Levie's regret minimization. tactics, not takeaways.
one summary, every tuesday.
the tactics that matter, each with a step to run. unsubscribe anytime.
FAQ
How do I stop negative thoughts immediately?
Do not try to push the thought away. Dr Julie Smith says trying not to have a thought keeps it there. Answer it with one real fact instead, like Martin Seligman does. If your mood will not shift, Smith says the body is often quicker than the mind: move, put on music, or talk to someone.
Why do I always think the worst?
Martin Seligman says it is the default. We come from ancestors who survived the ice ages by expecting trouble, so the brain leans toward catastrophizing. Optimism is the part that has to be learned, for example by arguing back with evidence and running the worst, best and most likely case.
What is learned optimism?
It is Martin Seligman's idea that optimism can be trained. In his research, pessimists explain a failure as about them, lasting forever and ruining everything. Optimists say things like I had a hangover or I did not try hard enough, which is temporary. Disputing your harshest thoughts is how you move toward the second style.
Do positive affirmations work for negative thoughts?
Dr Julie Smith says they help most when they are instructions. If you repeat a line you do not believe, your mind tends to argue back with reasons it is not true. Try a line that tells you what to do in a hard moment instead of what you are.
How do I stop negative thoughts at night?
Martin Seligman says he still wakes at 4 in the morning with the voice, and argues back with a real fact, like a recent time it went fine. Keep a note by your bed for the thought and the fact. For better sleep in general, see our post on how to sleep better.
What is the difference between negative thoughts and overthinking?
A negative thought is one harsh story, like I will get fired. Rumination is when it loops. Dr Sahar Yousef says replaying it deepens the loop, so name why it is there and move your attention. For endless what-ifs and decisions, see our post on how to stop overthinking.




