Position As Soda Not Health Drink
Match your tagline to how people actually use the product.
Identify the real-world occasion customers use your product for and rewrite your tagline to match that emotional use case.
"When we first launched it was apple cider vinegar prebiotics like super simple gut health"Allison Ellsworth · 20:56 ↗
Poppi started as Mother Beverage, a gut-health focused apple cider vinegar drink sold at farmers markets. The branding emphasized prebiotics and digestive benefits. After securing a deal on Shark Tank, Ellsworth and her team took nine months off the market to rebrand. They shifted the positioning entirely. The tagline changed from "Be Gut Happy, Be Gut Healthy" to "Soda's Back, Better Than Ever." The packaging became vibrant and colorful to stand out on shelves against dull health drinks. They stopped leading with ingredients like ashwagandha or lion's mane and started leading with flavor profiles like cola and root beer. Ellsworth notes that consumers wanted the nostalgia and emotion of soda without the sugar crash. This shift moved the buying decision from the head to the heart. By tapping into the emotional connection people have with soda, Poppi expanded its total addressable market from niche health enthusiasts to the general population. The health benefits became a secondary surprise rather than the primary pitch.
